DHS Replacing the Traditional H-1B Lottery Selection System

What’s Changed, What’s Staying the Same, and How Should Employers and Applicants Respond

1. Executive Overview

The U.S. Department of Homeland Security and USCIS have finalized a major change to how H-1B cap registrations are selected. The process is still called a “lottery,” but it is no longer purely random. DHS has introduced a weighted selection system that adjusts the probability of selection based on wage levels. Each beneficiary will be entered a certain number of times based on the offered position’s Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) wage level.

This change does not eliminate eligibility. It changes odds, not access.

  • Some registrants will have higher statistical odds of getting picked
  • Many applicants will experience no eligibility change

Visual: Old vs New Selection Logic (Quick Snapshot)

Feature Old Lottery New Weighted Lottery
Random selection Yes Yes (partial)
Wage influence None Yes (weighted)
Hard wage cutoff No No
Lower-wage eligibility Yes Yes
Guaranteed outcomes No No
Beneficiary Centric Yes Yes

2. What’s Changing in the H-1B Selection System

The Prior Framework

Under the old system, every eligible registration had identical odds, regardless of role, location, or wage.

The New Framework

  • Registrations are weighted (not ranked)
  • Higher SOC wage levels receive more entries
  • Lower SOC wage levels remain eligible
  • Selection is still partially random

Visual: How Weighting Works (Conceptual)

Wage Level Relative Selection Weight
Level I One entry
Level II Two entries
Level III Three entries
Level IV Four entries
OR
Check My Eligibility

3. New Procedures and New Information Required

What Employers Must Prepare Differently

The registration form will be expanded significantly, and registration quality will have significant downstream consequences.

Key scrutiny points:

  • SOC code accuracy
  • Wage level justification
  • Worksite location

Visual: Pre- vs Post-Change Risk Profile

Stage Old Risk Level New Risk Level
Registration accuracy Medium High
Wage alignment Low High
SOC mismatch Medium High
Documentation gaps Medium High

4. The $100,000 Fee Reality Check

Confirmed Facts

There is no $100,000 H-1B filing fee imposed by the finalized rule.

What Is Being Discussed Publicly

Large fee figures referenced in the media relate to policy discussions, not enacted law.

Visual: Fact vs Fiction

Claim Status
$100,000 fee applies to all H-1Bs False
Fee increase is finalized False
Future fees possible Unconfirmed
Standard employers affected now No

Get A Free Visa Assessment
From An Experienced Immigration Attorney
Trust Symbol

5. Geography, Wage Levels, and the Skill Proxy Problem

Why Smaller Cities May Benefit, and Why Wage ≠ Skill

This change makes one thing clear: location now matters more, but not in obvious ways.

5.1 How Wage Levels Are Actually Determined (Regulatory Fact)

Wage levels are based on local labor markets, not national prestige.

Factors include:

  • Occupation (SOC)
  • Worksite location
  • Experience and responsibility

Visual: Same Job, Different City, Different Wage Level

Role City Wage Wage Level
Software Engineer San Jose, CA $264,514 Level IV
Software Engineer Des Moines, IA $138,507 Level IV

5.2 Why Smaller Cities Can Remain Competitive

Prevailing wages are determined locally, not nationally:

  • Non-tech hubs are not automatically disadvantaged
  • Level III–IV roles outside major cities can remain competitive
  • Healthcare, education, manufacturing, research remain viable

Visual: Geographic Impact Map (Web Interactive)

Interactive on web:

A map allowing users to select:

  • City
  • Occupation
  • Wage
  • Resulting wage levels

5.3 Where the Model Strains (Expert Interpretation)

Policy analyst Jeremy Neufeld highlights that wage-based weighting can prioritize seniority rather than skill scarcity.

Visual: Counterintuitive Outcomes Table

Role City Wage Level Relative Odds
Pediatric Surgeon PA $260,000 Level I Lower
Market Research Analyst OH $75,000 Level IV Higher
Hardware Engineer AZ $130,000 Level I Lower
HR Manager MO $93,000 Level II Higher

This does not indicate a system error. It reflects how prevailing wage mechanics function.


6. Can Everyone Still Apply for H-1B?

Visual: Eligibility Continuity Checklist:

Category Still Eligible?
F-1 students Yes
OPT / STEM OPT Yes
Startups Yes
Nonprofits Yes
Mid-size companies Yes

7. How to Use These Changes to Your Advantage

Employer Strategy Dashboard:

Area Action
SOC & Level selection Conservative, defensible
Wage-setting Market-aligned
Documentation Front-loaded
Timing Early preparation

Candidate Strategy Dashboard

Area Action
Role clarity Understand classification
Education match Document alignment
Timing Prepare pre-registration

8. What Has NOT Changed

Visual: Stability Matrix

Requirement Changed?
Specialty occupation No
Cap numbers No
Randomness Reduced, not removed
Lower-wage eligibility Still allowed

9. Next Steps for Employers and Applicants

Employer Checklist

  • Audit SOC and wage level alignment
  • Review registration practices
  • Train HR and recruiting teams
  • Prepare documentation before registration opens

Applicant Checklist

  • Confirm job classification accuracy
  • Avoid last-minute changes
  • Coordinate closely with your employer
  • Seek legal guidance early

10. Frequently Asked Questions

1.Is the H-1B lottery gone?

No. It remains a lottery, now with weighted probabilities.

2.Is this only for high-paid workers?

No. Lower-wage roles remain eligible.

3.Can startups still file?

The PERM process ends if you’re laid off and the employer does not continue it. It is employer-specific and cannot be transferred. You must restart the PERM process with a new sponsor.

4.Does job location matter?

Yes, relative to local wage standards.

5.Is this permanent?

It is a finalized rule. Any change would require new rulemaking.


11. Conclusion: What This Means for H-1B Cap 2026 and Beyond

These changes will certainly affect how employers will make job offers, review minimum requirements and determine work locations. However, all beneficiaries continue to remain eligible for selection I the H-1B Lottery.

For employers and professionals who plan early, classify roles accurately, and document carefully, opportunity remains firmly intact.


Next Steps, Free Visa Assessment with VisaPro
If you want to understand how your specific role, city, and wage level may be treated under the new weighted selection system, individualized analysis is essential.

VisaPro offers a free visa assessment with an experienced immigration attorney to help you:

  • Evaluate your H-1B cap strategy
  • Review job classification and wage alignment
  • Identify risks before registration opens

Schedule your free visa assessment here:
https://www.visapro.com/service-options/consult-attorney/immigration-lawyer-consultation/


What VisaPro Customers Are Saying

The US [B-1] Visa has always been a tough ride, and being denied a few times it makes it even worse. But thanks to VisaPro and their meticulous processing I was granted a Visa. I would like to thank you and all the people involved in making this a success. I would like to recommend VisaPro to all those who seek peace of mind and hassle free Visa processing.”

Get a Free Visa Assessment